Can you consume coffee or tea with milk?
Like me, most people generally need to start the day with a cup of tea or coffee. I like taking my black tea with a splash of milk to balance out the flavour. The 16/8 intermittent fasting diet requires you to fast for 16 hours and eat during the 8 hours. During the 16 hours, you are suppose to not consume anything with calories, which means that milk should not be consumed if you wish to stick to the diet properly. However, depending on what your goals are, there is some leeway to this!
Drinking straight tea or black coffee is 0 calories which means that it’s allowed during your fasting zone. Whereas, if you were to drink a Starbucks salted caramel cream nitro cold brew, it would have broken your fast. This is because the grande (473ml) without any customisation would have been 230 calories. This is around the same amount of calories in a glazed donut from Dunkin’ Donut.
All of the add ons to the drink such as sugar and milk will add in fat and calories. Both of these are something that you should avoid during your fasting period. While black coffee is just 0 calories, it’s adding the milk or sugar that loads up more calories into your diet. If you were to consume it, it means that your body will be able to utilise fuel from something other than your body’s storage. The more calories you provide your body, the more it has to use as energy which means that your fast is broken.
In some situations you can drink coffee or tea with milk
In a true fast, putting a splash of milk or cream in your tea or coffee will definitely be considered as breaking your fast. However, for some people who absolutely must have a splash of milk or cream, it’s not the end of the world. Dr. Jason Fung, one of the leading experts on intermittent fasting have stated that a little milk or cream is alright, as long as there’s no sweeteners or sugar. He’s noticed that allowing this had improved people’s compliance to the fasting rules.
It mostly depends on what your goal of doing intermittent fasting is. Some people fast for weight loss, reduce insulin resistance, lowering their risk of type 2 diabetes, reducing inflammation in the body or just as a challenge. Having a bit of cream or milk won’t inhibit fat burning in your body, but it will affect autophagy negatively. Sometimes, this might not matter if it doesn’t connect to what you’re doing intermittent fasting for.
Coffee or tea with milk for those who want to achieve autophagy?
Interest for autophagy has been increasing recently. Autophagy is sometimes achieved through intermittent fasting. The idea of autophagy is that because there is no external sources of fuel in your body, the body should start to eat itself. Hence the term auto (self) and phage (eat). It’s believed that the body can use and recycle your own damaged cells and proteins to create new and healthier versions of it. People believe that it’s good for preventing yourself from diseases such as cancer. Evidence has suggested that autophagy influences a wide range of tissues and organs. However, you would have to fast for at least around 20 hours. Dr. Jason Fung suggested that it happens “probably in the later stages of a long fast – somewhere around 20 to 24 hours.”
While you are fed, insulin is increased and therefore the rate of autophagy is low. As insulin drops while fasting, autophagy will increase. Autophagy is suppressed when there is insulin resistance, this might explain why people with diabetes or obesity have a higher risk of negative effects.
If you are not fasting for autophagy, then there is a slight leeway for you to have a bit of milk or cream in your drink. However, do not forget it is all about the calories in the end. The calories in milk depends of what type of milk you take.
– A tablespoon of nonfat milk is 5 calories
– A tablespoon of 2% milk is 9 calories
– A tablespoon of whole milk is 9 calories
– A tablespoon of soy milk is 8 calories
– A tablespoon of cream is 29 calories
– A tablespoon of nonfat milk is 5 calories
Therefore, in my opinion, taking a coffee/tea with a tablespoon of milk or cream should be fine. As long as you are not drinking 5-10 cups during your fasting period, you will be safe to have a cuppa or two.
On the other note, plain green tea actually helps fasting! Dr. Jason Fung actually asks his patients to drink black or green tea during fasting periods. The green tea catechins can help support the weight loss. Catechins are also present in black tea, however there is much higher concentration of catechins in green tea than black. Evidence shows that green tea catechins can help lower ghrelin (hunger hormone) and therefore decreases your hunger pangs. It also has the ability to block carbohydrate absorption. One study presented that the amount of extra calories burned was around 106 calories a day through drinking a beverage with caffeine, green tea catechins and calcium 3 times a day. The benefits of green tea for weight loss might not be high, but if you were to consider around 100 calories a day, it’ll add up to 1000 calories in 10 days.
I like to drink matcha during my fast as it has a bit more caffeine and also more green tea catechins. It is a super boost that really helps pump me up for the day. When purchasing matcha, you should always make sure you read the ingredients to be sure that you are buying something that is pure matcha and does not have any added sugars.
If you want to stay safe from the milk in coffee or tea, you can also drink water. Drinking water is pretty important during your fast. Sometimes you might mistaken thirst with hunger or drinking water might help you feel fuller or stuffed. Water is very important to your body. If you find the taste of water bland, you could spice it up by adding some lemon, lime or cucumber slices. Adding a slice or a squeeze won’t add any number of calories that will have effect on your intermittent fasting.
In the end, it’s all up to you. It is your diet and your body, you should have complete control of it. While it is safest to stick to water, black coffee or straight tea during intermittent fasting, you should not do something that will make you detest it. If you need to drink a coffee with a splash of milk, do it. You are doing intermittent fasting to improve your life and if that is what it takes to help your fast then it is worth it.
This page contains Affiliate Links, which means as an Amazon Associate I may earn commissions through links you make purchases through.
6 thoughts on “Can I Drink Coffee/Tea with Milk on the 16:8 Intermittent Fasting?”
Very interesting post.
I’m a big believer in caloric restriction (still eating within the range of calories required per day, but towards the low end of that range) but I think I should get on this 16:8 thing too for a while. The autophagy stuff is interesting…
Wow, I’ve been doing it wrong for years! I thought intermittent fasting meant no food, not “no calories.” I eat between 11 a.m. and 5 p.m. (sometimes it changes on weekends) but do have a smoothie. I do get the results though — high energy, weight stabilization, sleep well … I’m going to stick with what I’m doing even though you’re right 🙂
Thanks for all this information!